Yesterday, our panelist Jon Teitel unveiled his weekly bracket based on what he believes the Selection Committee will pick through yesterday’s games. Today, our panelist John Stalica unveils his bracket based on where he believes all the teams currently stand. Here is the bracket below:
COMMENTS FROM JOHN
– Teams like Florida State, Arizona and North Carolina were also considered for the top line, but at the end of the day I still believe that Nova, Gonzaga, Kansas and Baylor have enough quality in their profile to remain on the top line through a very turbulent week. The Seminoles certainly have the quality wins that scream 1-seed, but 3 of their 4 losses are against teams not in this field. Still, with 8 wins against likely NCAA Tournament teams and 5 other wins against possible NCAA Tournament teams, they are my top 2-seed.
– Butler is still an interesting team to place if you consider the above criteria – they also have 8 wins against potential NCAA Tournament teams and 6 wins against teams that also have serious postseason aspirations. However, of their 3 losses against non-NCAA teams, 2 of them (Indiana State and St. John’s) preclude them from getting any higher this week. Losing their last 2 games at home is another danger sign, especially with trips to Marquette, Villanova, and Xavier still on the horizon.
– Both Wisconsin and UCLA were #16 and #17 on my seed list, respectively. The Badgers have a better record in a better league against better competition (top-to-bottom), and UCLA’s signature win is starting to fade thanks to Kentucky’s slide.
– And how about Kentucky being below a protected seed? I think Kentucky’s hiccup is only temporary, but they were potentially looking at a 4-game losing streak had they lost to Georgia at home. They should easily handle LSU at home, but they’re entering another dangerous 3-game stretch at Alabama, at home against Tennessee and at Georgia. No real opportunity to bolster the profile, but plenty of chances to ding it.
– While Creighton is all over the place after the Mo Watson injury, Xavier has won a pair of close ones (including a win at Creighton) after Sumner’s injury and suddenly find themselves in 2nd place in the Big East. Their next 5 games give them a chance to climb back up – a homestand against DePaul and Villanova and then a 3-game roadie at Providence and 2 bubble teams (Marquette and Seton Hall).
– I expect my most controversial pick by far to be the Wichita State pick. Their resume doesn’t in and of itself scream a 9-seed, but they have really caught fire since starting play in the Missouri Valley. They destroyed Illinois State at home and it would take a collapse for me to think that they can’t run the table the rest of the regular season. We joke about “not wanting to play X team in March”, but I’d much rather be paired up with an Arkansas or Dayton team than I would a Wichita State team.
– California would be my last team in the field, but bracketing rules bumped them up to an 11 and Michigan down to a 12 because the placement of South Carolina doesn’t allow for a potential 1st-round game against either Michigan or Tennessee.
– Chad mentioned Alabama as another team he’s added to his board that has an outside shot at getting enough quality wins to make the field. I propose the Iowa Hawkeyes – they have a lot of work to do, but all of their remaining opponents are in the Top 100 of the RPI. Suppose they get 2 road wins out of a group including Minnesota, Michigan State, Maryland and Wisconsin AND win their 3 remaining home games against Illinois, Indiana and Penn State. They are the Big 10’s equivalent of Syracuse this season.
– Other at-large teams considered: Illinois State, Texas Tech, Clemson, Wake Forest, Georgia Tech, Rhode Island, Memphis and Utah. When Syracuse can finally win an ACC road game of note, I’ll consider them.
COMMENTS FROM CHAD
– I don’t have too many complaints about John’s protected seeds (seed lines 1-4) and I completely agree with his decision to leave Kansas and Baylor on the 1 line. My biggest change would be to put Florida and Kentucky up there, likely in place of Purdue and Cincinnati. I am not ready to write off Kentucky entirely and I think Florida’s power rating numbers are so good that they need to be protected seed (not to mention what they did to UK on Saturday). I also would have Oregon on the 2 line — though I may be giving too much credit to them for what they did to Arizona.
– John is right that he is insane in his seeding of Wichita State. They have ONE (yes ONE) top 100 win and it was over an Illinois State team that will not be getting an at-large bid (the Redbirds may still belong Under Consideration but they will have no more chances for a statement win until the MVC finals — and if they win that game they are in anyhow). I can live with them being above the First Four teams, especially with their power ratings, but the 9 line is 2 lines too high.
– I hate to do this. I really hate to do this. Kansas State is too low in John’s bracket. It pains me to argue for Bruce Weber’s team, but I think they are closer to wearing white in the first round after the win at Baylor then to playing in Dayton. I would have them on the 9 line.
– I do not understand at all why Michigan is in this field. Georgia Tech has a better resume. Rhode Island has a better resume. Texas Tech has a better resume. Clemson, Georgetown and Syracuse all might even be better. The Wolverines have only two wins away from home, both on neutral courts, against SMU and Marquette. Their only home win against a team in this field is Indiana. So in other words, no road wins and no wins over anyone above the 7 line. That is not a tournament team. In fact, John says he will not consider Syracuse until they win an ACC road game of note. Yet he put Michigan in without a Big Ten (or any) road win of note. Make up your damn mind!!!
COMMENTS FROM DAVID
-I think John nailed the #1 seeds. I know we saw some carnage over the weekend with two of the four losing at home to unranked teams, but at the end of the day it is one game out of thirty, and all of the rest of the games those teams have played still add up to being more than anyone who isn’t on his #1 line.
-I’m not as big on Cincinnati. The record is bloated, but that is the only earmark that they’re meeting when it comes to being a protected seed. Protected seeds typically have multiple wins against teams in the top half of the bracket, and manage to get some of those away from home. Cincinnati will not have that. Not only that, but I don’t think they look as good on the court as any of the teams he has on his #5 line, or for that matter even some of them on the #6 line. They’re running roughshod over a league that has an SMU team that will be inside the bubble, a couple of NIT teams, and that’s it. And, they just didn’t have the big wins out of conference they need to end up as a protected seed. I will now sit back and watch the real selection committee give them a protected seed.
-I disagree with Wichita State on the #9 line, but having said that it isn’t entirely insane. Let’s just say that if this were debate class and I was asked to make that argument, I could. They have an abundance of road wins against teams that, while not tournament teams, still typically play well at home. And…well….that’s really it. The paper doesn’t support this, but when I look at John’s #10 line, I believe Wichita State to be better on the court than any of those teams. Arkansas just lost at Missouri for crissake, and Dayton has had to sweat out a few games, and Miami and Seton Hall have lost more big games than they’ve won. They all have better paper than Wichita, but if Wichita were to meet any of them on equal terms I’d go with the Shockers.
-Middle Tennessee on the #11 line seems about right. Right on the fringe of the bubble and they still have a chance if they win out, but only a chance and not an assurance.
-Chad already discussed Michigan, and I agree with him. That’s a crazy selection.
The Hoops HD Report: February 6th
It’s the day after the Super Bowl, college basketball is now the biggest sport in the country, and Chad is joined by a full Hoops HD Panel. They recap one of the craziest days of college basketball that we can remember where we saw six top ten teams lose, and of those three lost at home to unranked teams. They discuss what this means for the NCAA Tournament as Kansas State, Oklahoma State, and Iowa State all picked up huge wins for on their resume. From there, they run through all of the conferences and recap all the action, including a crazy finish between VCU and Saint Bonaventure in the Atlantic Ten. They also preview this week’s upcoming action, and give their Final Four and National Title picks.
And for all you radio lovers, below is an mp3 version of the show…